Haan, kuch log isay bid'at kehte hain, lekin yeh article Ahle Sunnat ke manhaj (Hanafi, Shafai, Maliki, Hanbali) par mabni hai.
There is no direct Hadith where the Prophet (PBUH) prescribed "Fatiha" alone for the dead. However, scholars agree that reciting Quran and sending the reward ( Isaal-e-Sawab ) is permissible. The specific "Fatiha gathering" with food is a cultural practice, not a religious obligation. fatiha ka tarika in roman english
Fatiha is a beautiful act of remembrance and a gift of mercy for the departed souls. While you can perform it at any time, the 3rd, 11th, 40th days, or annual anniversary ( barsi ) are culturally observed. Performing it with a group amplifies the reward and blessings. Haan, kuch log isay bid'at kehte hain, lekin
So, the is simply:
Khana saamne rakhna lazmi nahi hai, lekin barkat ke liye aur Isale-Sawab ki niyat se rakhna behtar hai. The specific "Fatiha gathering" with food is a